The Fifth Element (1997): A Flawed, Brilliant Movie That Earned Its Classic Status

Let’s get something straight up front: The Fifth Element is not a perfect movie. I’m not going to pretend otherwise, because that kind of dishonesty doesn’t do the film any favors. What it is, is a movie so confident in its own weirdness that its flaws stopped mattering to millions of people a long time ago — and I think that distinction is worth actually talking about instead of just repeating “it’s a classic” and moving on.

What It’s Actually About

Luc Besson’s sci-fi opera follows Korben Dallas (Bruce Willis), a washed-up former special forces major turned flying-taxi driver in 23rd-century New York, who ends up with a woman named Leeloo (Milla Jovovich) literally falling into his cab. Leeloo is the “fifth element” — a genetically perfect being who, alongside four mystical stones, is humanity’s only defense against a great evil that resurfaces every five thousand years. Standing in the way: Zorg (Gary Oldman), an industrialist working for that evil for his own profit, and a supporting cast that includes Ian Holm as a harried priest and Chris Tucker as Ruby Rhod, a radio host who is exactly as loud as that description implies.

Besson started writing this story when he was sixteen. He was thirty-eight when it finally hit theaters, after the production collapsed once in 1992 and had to be rebuilt from scratch years later (Wikipedia). That’s not a fun fact — that’s context for why this movie feels like nothing else. It’s a passion project that had two decades to marinate into something singular.

What I Genuinely Love About It

The world-building is the reason people are still talking about this movie almost thirty years later. Besson brought in comic artists Jean “Moebius” Giraud and Jean-Claude Mézières to design the future — the flying-taxi concept came directly from Mézières’s earlier work — and the team produced more than 8,000 drawings to build out a New York City that still looks genuinely inventive today (Wikipedia). Besson also insisted on shooting most action in broad daylight, deliberately avoiding the gloomy, rain-slicked cyberpunk look every other sci-fi film of the era was chasing. That single choice gives the film a “cheerfully crazy” energy that still feels distinct.

Then there’s Jean Paul Gaultier’s costume work, which is doing more heavy lifting than most viewers give it credit for. Nine hundred individual costumes for the Fhloston Paradise sequence alone, each one checked personally by Gaultier every morning, designed to be “intellectually transgressive” and to mess with gender and sexuality norms in ways mainstream studio sci-fi simply wasn’t doing in 1997 (Wikipedia). That’s not decoration. That’s a director letting a genuine fashion visionary co-author the film’s identity.

And then there’s the opera scene. Diva Plavalaguna performing “Il dolce suono,” the mad scene from Donizetti’s Lucia di Lammermoor, sung by Albanian soprano Inva Mula, intercut with Korben Dallas fighting for his life two rooms over — it’s one of the best marriages of high art and pulp action I’ve ever seen in a blockbuster, and it still gives me chills (Wikipedia). Roger Ebert, no easy mark, gave the film three stars and called it “one of the great goofy movies,” praising its “richness of imagery” (Wikipedia). He wasn’t wrong.

Where I’ll Push Back on It

Here’s my honest note, and it’s the one I’ll defend without flinching: the opening act is slow. Before Leeloo crashes into Korben’s cab and the film finds its rhythm, there’s a decent chunk of setup — the 1914 Egyptian temple sequence, the exposition about the Great Evil and the stones — that asks for patience the rest of the film hasn’t earned yet. It’s necessary table-setting, but it’s the one stretch where the film’s momentum genuinely lags before it locks into gear.

I’ll also say the critical reception at the time was more split than the film’s current cult status suggests, and that split was fair. Variety‘s Todd McCarthy called it “a hodgepodge of elements that don’t comfortably coalesce,” and Slate‘s David Edelstein went further, calling it “one of the most unhinged” films he’d seen (Wikipedia). Chris Tucker’s performance as Ruby Rhod is the most divisive element in the entire film — some outlets, including Time, called him “the summer’s most outrageous special effect,” while others ranked his performance among the worst of the decade (Wikipedia). I land somewhere in between: he’s a lot, on purpose, and whether that works for you says more about your tolerance for maximalism than it does about the film’s quality.

The Rotten Tomatoes critics’ score sits at a respectable 70%, but Metacritic pegs it at 52 — “mixed or average” (Wikipedia). Both numbers are honestly correct. This was always a movie that critics were going to argue about, and it still is.

Why It’s a Staple and a Classic Anyway

Here’s the case I’ll actually make, and it’s the one that matters: The Fifth Element didn’t become a classic by being flawless. It became one by being unmistakably itself in a genre that too often plays it safe.

It was the most expensive European film ever made at the time of release, made back nearly three times its $90 million budget, and remained the highest-grossing French film internationally until 2011 (Wikipedia). The Visual Effects Society later placed it among the fifty most influential visual effects films ever made, and Time Out ranked it 42nd on its list of the 100 best sci-fi movies (Wikipedia). Critic Mark Kermode has described it as one of the most divisive films among his own readers — simultaneously nominated as the best and the worst summer blockbuster ever made (Wikipedia). That kind of split reaction isn’t a weakness. It’s the fingerprint of a movie that took a real swing instead of playing to consensus.

That’s the actual lesson here, and it’s one I think about a lot when people ask what separates a “cult classic” from a movie that just fades away: audiences don’t remember safe. They remember commitment. Besson gave every department — production design, costuming, music, performance — full permission to go as far as it wanted, and enough of those swings connected that the film has outlived nearly every other big-budget sci-fi movie released that same year.

The Verdict

The Fifth Element asks you to sit through a slower opening and a genuinely divisive Chris Tucker performance, and in exchange gives you one of the most visually inventive, sincerely weird, and quietly influential science fiction films ever put on a studio budget. I don’t think it’s a perfect movie. I think it’s a braver one than most, and almost thirty years later, that’s exactly why it’s still on every “essential sci-fi” list worth reading.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *