Countdown to Halloween: Hocus Pocus (1993) Review

Here’s an unpopular opinion I’ll die on, at least with critics: Hocus Pocus is a better Halloween movie than its reviews ever gave it credit for. It’s the first pick in my Countdown to Halloween, and I’m starting with it because no other movie has earned its place in October quite the way this one has. It earned that place slowly, one rerun at a time, after nearly everyone wrote it off.

This Hocus Pocus review isn’t going to pretend the movie is flawless. It isn’t. But I’ve watched it more Octobers than I can count, and it’s one of my personal favorites for reasons that have very little to do with whether it’s tidy.

What Hocus Pocus is about

Three witch sisters, Winifred, Sarah and Mary Sanderson, are hanged in Salem in 1693 after stealing the life of a young girl. Three hundred years later, on Halloween night, a teenager named Max, newly moved to town and sure the whole holiday is a scam, lights a candle that brings them back. Max, his little sister Dani, his crush Allison and a cat named Thackery Binx have until sunrise to stop the sisters from staying for good.

Kenny Ortega directed it from a screenplay by Mick Garris and Neil Cuthbert, with Bette Midler, Sarah Jessica Parker and Kathy Najimy as the sisters and Omri Katz, Thora Birch and Vinessa Shaw as the kids (Wikipedia). It’s rated PG and runs about 96 minutes (Box Office Mojo). It’s a family movie, and a good one to put on with kids in the room.

The numbers behind a famous flop

I’ll say the quiet part out loud: Hocus Pocus was a flop. Disney released it on July 16, 1993, a Halloween movie in the middle of summer, on the same day as Free Willy. It opened in fourth place with about $8.1 million and fell out of the top ten within two weeks (Wikipedia). On a reported $28 million budget, its original run brought in about $39.5 million worldwide (Box Office Mojo).

Critics didn’t help. Roger Ebert gave it one star. It still sits at 42% with critics on Rotten Tomatoes, across 65 reviews (Rotten Tomatoes), and 43 on Metacritic.

Now look at the other column. Audiences on Rotten Tomatoes rate it 72% across more than 250,000 ratings (Rotten Tomatoes). Its total gross with rereleases is about $48.7 million, including roughly $5.4 million from a 30th-anniversary run in 2023, three decades after it first left theaters (Box Office Mojo). Annual October airings on Disney Channel and Freeform turned it into the network’s sleeper hit (Wikipedia). When Disney finally made Hocus Pocus 2 in 2022, it became the company’s most-viewed film premiere in the U.S. over its first three days (Wikipedia).

A movie doesn’t get a sequel 29 years later because of its reviews. It gets one because people never stopped watching.

Why the Sanderson sisters still work

The reason is the three women at the center of it. Bette Midler plays Winifred like a diva who has been denied her final bow for three centuries, and she’s having the time of her life. Sarah Jessica Parker plays Sarah as a sweet, slightly lost singer who drifts through every scene. Kathy Najimy plays Mary as the sister who’s always trying to keep everyone happy, nose first.

They work as a unit. Their comic timing is so tight that the movie basically turns into a stage show whenever they’re together, and the best stretch of the film is exactly that: Winifred taking over a town Halloween party and performing “I Put a Spell on You.” Even Gene Siskel, who called the movie dreadful, admitted that one number worked. I’d gently push back on him and say it’s the key to the whole thing. Hocus Pocus is a musical comedy that happens to have witches in it.

Where it falls short

I’m not going to pretend otherwise: the kids’ half of the movie is weaker than the witches’ half. Max is more annoyed than interesting for a while, the teen romance is thin, and a few jokes are aimed at a 1993 audience in a way that doesn’t age well. The plot also runs on coincidence, especially once everyone is racing around town in the dark.

None of that ruins it. It just tells you where the movie’s heart is, which is with the Sanderson sisters and with Binx, the cursed cat who has spent 300 years trying to make up for a single night. The cat is the most moving thing in the film. I didn’t expect to be saying that the first time I saw it.

Why it opens my countdown

Every October I want a movie that feels like the season itself: crunchy leaves, porch lights, a little spooky, never actually frightening. Hocus Pocus is that feeling on film. It’s set on Halloween night in Salem, it looks like a storybook, and it ends at sunrise with everyone home safe.

It’s also a rare movie that works for every age at once. Kids get witches, a talking cat and a zombie who keeps losing his head. Adults get Bette Midler at full volume. That’s why it keeps coming back every fall while slicker movies fade.

The verdict

The verdict: Hocus Pocus is a messy, warm, very funny family Halloween movie carried by three performers who understood exactly what it needed. Critics judged it as a summer comedy in 1993. Audiences judged it as an October tradition, and they were right.

That’s the first pick in my Countdown to Halloween. Next week I’m going a little darker, but not much.

James Atkinson, October 12, 2026

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *